Fresh seafood is just one of the highlights of a trip to the Florida Keys. Islamorada, a narrow chain of small islands in the Upper Keys, is one of the best small towns to taste local fare and fresh catches. Known as the “sportfishing capital of the world,” Islamorada’s dining scene is heavily shaped by the angler community; naturally, it has several great eateries to enjoy world-class seafood.
Kaiyo Grill & Sushi, located in the heart of Upper Matecumbe Key in the middle of the Arts & Cultural District, serves up dishes that bring a taste of the Keys with an Asian twist. The restaurant features an island-Asian menu and a wood-fired grill, bringing together local seafood and bold flavors. With a newly added full bar alongside beer, wine and sake selections, Kaiyo is a must-visit for seafood and cocktail pairings.
Key West Shrimp with a Gin and Tonic
This gluten-free starter features local pink shrimp tossed with cucumber, soy-cured watermelon, cherry tomatoes and a light soy vinaigrette. Pink shrimp has a beautifully delicate sweetness elevated by fresh produce, while the vinaigrette adds a necessary savory note for balance.
The best cocktails for seafood ensure subtle flavors aren’t lost in the mix; a gin and tonic keeps things light and refreshing. Gin’s botanicals complement the fresh ingredients, the lime adds a bright citrus kick, and the tonic’s slight bitterness and carbonation refresh the palate between bites.
Korean Fried Grouper Bites with a Japanese Whisky Highball
Grouper is a beloved Florida Keys fish because of its mild, slightly sweet flavor and firm white flesh. At Kaiyo, pieces of grouper are fried until crispy and served as an appetizer with kimchi aioli for a creamy tang and touch of fermented chili heat. The combination adds more richness and spice than a simple fried fish starter.
A Japanese whisky highball, made with whisky and soda water, offers a crisp counterpoint. The bubbles help cut through the fried coating and creamy aioli, while the whisky’s subtle malt and oak notes bring depth without overpowering the grouper.
Yellowtail Tiradito Spoons with a Margarita
Yellowtail has a smooth, tender texture and a rich yet clean flavor that stands up next to bold accompaniments. The Yellowtail Tiradito Spoons layer raw yellowtail with jalapeño, goat cheese, seasonal apples, cilantro pesto, sriracha, black sea salt and truffle ponzu. The apple adds sweetness and crunch, while the jalapeño and sriracha bring heat. Goat cheese lends creaminess, and truffle ponzu ties everything together with citrusy, savory notes.
A classic margarita is a fitting choice for this mix of flavors. Tequila, lime juice and orange liqueur introduce bright citrus notes to complement the ponzu and apple; the lime’s acidity balances the goat cheese and helps temper the heat.
Macadamia Hogfish Roll with a Daiquiri
Hogfish is another Keys favorite for its subtle, sweet white flesh and tender texture. This specialty roll includes fried hogfish with mango, pineapple, mango sauce and kimchi aioli. The crispy coating is a nice contrast for the juicy tropical fruit, and everything pairs well with the creamy, tangy aioli.
The white rum, sugar and fresh lime juice in a classic daiquiri fit right in with these island-inspired flavors. Rum, mango and pineapple complement one another, while the lime brightens the fried fish and creamy aioli.
Wahoo Nigiri or Sashimi with Sake Martini
Wahoo is found in the warm offshore waters around the Florida Keys. Kaiyo’s wahoo is served as either nigiri or sashimi, offering two ways to appreciate the fish’s firm texture and clean, mild flavor. Sashimi lets the wahoo speak for itself; nigiri includes seasoned rice, which some sushi lovers prefer over sashimi style.
A sake martini puts a Japanese spin on the classic cocktail, which combines sake with vodka for a smooth, understated drink. Sake’s rice notes work perfectly alongside straightforward nigiri and sashimi. The cocktail’s clean finish also leaves room for the wahoo’s mild flavor to come through.
Whole Caribbean Lobster and a Chardonnay
Wood-grilled whole Caribbean lobster is a standout on Kaiyo’s menu. This dish comes with a crab salad and shiitake béchamel for layers of shellfish, creamy richness and earthy flavors against the lobster’s naturally sweet, firm meat. The grilling brings a hint of smokiness that elevates this lobster beyond a classic preparation.
A fuller-bodied chardonnay with balanced acidity is a natural fit. The wine’s richness works well with the lobster and crab, while the acidity levels out the béchamel. Subtle oak notes also work well with the smoky grill and earthy shiitake mushrooms.
